Is Tyler Perry’s “House of Payne” TV’s Great Black Hope?

Tags: , ,


Come this fall there will be fewer of us on televison. Surprised? You shouldn’t be. I knew this was coming when I heard Khandi Alexander and Gary Dourdan where out of their respective CSI’s (with Dourdan’s departure both gruesome and definitive). But what does surprise me is that it looks like the NAACP feels the need to study such an obvious problem and issue another report (which will be coming soon). Perhaps they should have stopped those ridiculous awards (that recognize brown faces whether the project is good or bad) and they would have realized this situation has been painfully apparent forever.

Anyway, Entertainment Weekly  did an in-depth story about the Fall 2008 television black-out. What stood out the most for me is that the writers reminded me that once a start-up network is successful it abandons its minority programming, passing the task along to the next up-and-coming network. So Fox passed the baton to UPN and the WB. When they merged and became the CW they kept us around for a season but now the baton has been passed to My Network TV (the people that gave Flavor Flav a sitcom). I don’t know about you but I find this thoroughly depressing. My Network TV would probably revive Homeboys from Outerspace if they had the chance too.

This brings me to Tyler Perry’s House of Payne, which has its home at TBS. In my opinion, this is far from great television (but it is light years ahead of Under One Roof). It reminds me of a sitcom from the 70s when the characters were thinly drawn and were allowed to be one of the following: understanding big black woman, loud black man, sassy kids, and the struggling single parent (I am still glad Alan Payne has a job.). But Perry threw in one more: the resident crack-head. Whether I like what Perry is doing or not is beside the point. He was powerful enough to get a $200 million syndication deal with TBS. And I witnessed scores of people waiting on line last year to meet the cast at the Essence Music Festival last year. So the sitcoms debut with over 5 million viewers doesn’t seem like much of a surprise.

So with much power comes much responsibility. Tyler needs to understand that with the number of us on the decline on the small screen, he has got to make a better show or add a stronger one to his development deal. Because we’d really like to see ourselves depicted as more than the sassy friend or sidekick.

 

 

Posted on June 18 2008 in Entertainment, Television, That Black Girl Blogging, That Black Girl Blogs

This post was written by:

Corynne - who has written 132 posts on That Black Girl Site.

Corynne Corbett is That Black Girl Blogging. She has always been passionate about empowering women to find ways to make their lives better. She has spent her career writing and editing for as well as speaking to women about their mental, physical and spiritual well-being. On this blog, Corbett will take a critical look at the images, issues and attitudes associated with us in popular culture and give you her view. Some of what she has noticed is strange, disturbing, comical and downright unbelievable. It makes her say hmmm…. or it makes her want to holler. Ultimately she wants you to know what effect these things have on black women’s lives.

Contact the author

2 Comments For This Post

  1. Jermaine Says:

    As it relates to blacks on television, I always ask myself, would I prefer to see no blacks on television, or more blacks on television filling the semi-stereotypical roles outlined above? It’s a tough choice. At the end of the day, we can only expect but so much cultural understanding and accurate representation on the part of these mega-corporations that own these networks. That’s why BET (pre-Viacom) is the single greatest dissappointment in the history of Black Media… but that’s another story.

    Tyler Perry strikes me as someone keenly in touch with the black experience, particularly, the neo-southern black experience (i just coined that term). He also strikes me as someone relatively talented in his own way; but for whatever reason, he’s unable to fully bring those two things - his cultural perception and talent - together in a meaningful way. His handling of tough topics (as in Daddy’s Little Girls, and Why Did I Get Married), comes off melodramatic and unbelievable at times, and his comedy can be, at times buffonish - almost to the point of minstrelsy. At the end of the day, my expectations for him are low - I’m guessing we’ll just get more of the same…

    Thank god we’ve at least got Spike on the big screen.

  2. Corynne Says:

    What fascinates me is what a huge following Perry has whether he produces quality or not.

Leave a Reply

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe

Design by Indiefamous.